COLOMBO, Sri Lanka – 04 November 2026 – In a significant development for a long-standing land dispute, the Court of Appeal of Sri Lanka has nullified previous rulings by both the Provincial High Court of Trincomalee and the Magistrate’s Court of Kantale. The case, titled Chinnaiyah Ramachandiran and Dhanalaxmy Ratnarajah v. Vallipuram Ratnasababathy Lohanantham, centered on a disagreement over property possession in Kantale and the proper application of the Primary Courts’ Procedure Act, No. 44 of 1979.
Background of the Dispute
The core of the legal battle revolved around a 14-perch portion of land identified as “Vithanaiyar Valavu” by the 1st Party-Petitioner-Respondent, Vallipuram Ratnasababathy Lohanantham (represented by his Power of Attorney Holder, Vallipuram Ratnasababathy Somananthan). Lohanantham claimed ownership through a Deed of Gift dated 01.01.2006 and alleged that the 2nd Party-Respondents-Appellants, Chinnaiyah Ramachandiran (since deceased, with Dhanalaxmy Ratnarajah substituted as 1(a) Appellant) and Dhanalaxmy Ratnarajah, forcibly entered and attempted to clear the land in June 2017, and later unloaded granite on it in August 2017.
Conversely, the Appellants contended that the disputed land was part of their “Kudiyiruppu Valavu,” 22 perches in extent, held under a Deed of Donation from 1948, and asserted continuous possession since approximately 1940. They denied any threat to the peace.
Progression through the Lower Courts
The initial proceedings commenced in the Primary Court of Kantale in October 2017. The learned Primary Court Judge, in an order dated 20.02.2018, dismissed the Respondent’s information, primarily on two grounds: the inability to clearly identify the disputed land due to conflicting descriptions and the fact that the alleged forcible entry of June 2017 fell outside the two-month statutory period for restoration relief under section 68(3) of the PCP Act.
Dissatisfied, Lohanantham appealed to the Provincial High Court of Trincomalee. On 26.09.2018, the High Court Judge overturned the Magistrate’s decision, holding that the Respondent had established possession, dispossession, and a threat to the peace, and directed that Lohanantham be restored to possession. The High Court Judge also analyzed title documents under section 69(2), concluding the Respondent had a right to possession.
Court of Appeal’s Analysis and Ruling
The Appellants then escalated the matter to the Court of Appeal, citing several grounds, including the High Court’s disregard for evidence of their long-standing possession, its failure to acknowledge the Magistrate’s personal observations of the land, and the absence of exceptional circumstances to warrant revisionary jurisdiction. Crucially, the Appellants argued that the High Court misdirected itself by applying section 69, which pertains to rights other than possession, to a pure possession dispute.
Justices Damith Thotawatte and K.M.S. Dissanayake delivered the judgment on 03.11.2026. The Court of Appeal emphasized that proceedings under the Primary Courts’ Procedure Act are summary and preventive, aimed at preventing breaches of the peace, and do not finally determine civil rights or ownership.
The Court found that:
- The High Court erred in deciding a pure possession dispute by evaluating title deeds under section 69, a provision explicitly stated to apply only to rights “other than the right to possession.”
- The High Court’s order lacked specific findings regarding the act and date of dispossession, which is indispensable for restoration orders under section 68(3) of the PCP Act.
- Both the Magistrate’s Court and the High Court failed to make a clear, reasoned finding identifying the corpus (the disputed land), despite conflicting descriptions from the parties. While the Magistrate concluded the corpus could not be identified, the High Court’s subsequent finding of possession and dispossession also lacked a clear identification of the land.
- The High Court’s failure to adequately address the Magistrate’s finding regarding the two-month statutory period for relief under section 68(3) was also a critical oversight.
In light of these misdirections by both lower courts in their application of the Primary Courts’ Procedure Act, the Court of Appeal set aside the orders of both the Provincial High Court of Trincomalee and the Magistrate’s Court of Kantale. The case has been remanded back to the Magistrate’s Court of Kantale for reconsideration and the making of an appropriate order in accordance with the law. The Magistrate has been granted discretion to call for further affidavits, if necessary, given the time elapsed.
No order was made as to costs.
Source: Read original document

