Colombo, 10 September 2026 – In a significant ruling handed down on 09 September 2026, the Supreme Court of Sri Lanka dismissed an appeal by Chandana Ukwatte, affirming the liability of a company’s principal officer for turnover taxes due from the company, even if not directly named as the “defaulter” in the initial certificate. The judgment, delivered in the case of Chandana Ukwatte v. Deputy Provincial Commissioner of Revenue Department of Inland Revenue (Western Province) and Others, clarifies the scope of accountability under the Financial Statute of the Western Province No. 6 of 1990.
Background to the Landmark Decision
The case originated from proceedings instituted by the Deputy Provincial Commissioner of Revenue (Western Province) for the recovery of turnover taxes allegedly due from The Three Coins Company (Pvt) Limited (referred to as the ‘3rd Respondent Company’). Following the company’s alleged default, a certificate was filed in the Magistrate’s Court of Colombo under Section 89(1) of the Financial Statute.
Chandana Ukwatte, then Chairman of the 3rd Respondent Company, submitted an affidavit on its behalf. The Magistrate’s Court, in its order dated 27 June 2006, held the 3rd Respondent Company responsible for the default and directed it to deposit the specified sum. Crucially, the Magistrate further ordered that should the company fail to make this payment, the sum be recovered as a fine from Ukwatte, imposing a suspended sentence of twelve months’ rigorous imprisonment in default.
Aggrieved by this, Ukwatte pursued appeals through the Provincial High Court and subsequently the Court of Appeal. Both courts dismissed his applications, with the Court of Appeal concluding that Ukwatte was a defaulter within the meaning of the Statute, making him liable for the fine and default sentence if the company failed to comply.
Key Questions Before the Supreme Court
The Supreme Court granted Special Leave to Appeal on two pivotal questions of law:
- Whether the Court of Appeal erred in failing to appreciate that proceedings under Section 89 of the Financial Statute could only be taken against the person cited as a defaulter in the certificate.
- Whether the Court of Appeal erred in failing to appreciate that the Petitioner (Ukwatte) was never cited as a defaulter and therefore could not have been treated as such in those proceedings.
Supreme Court’s Deliberation and Affirmation of Liability
The three-judge bench, comprising Justices A.L. Shiran Gooneratne, Dr. Sobhitha Rajakaruna, and Menaka Wijesundera, extensively considered the interplay between Sections 89, 85(3), and 21(1) of the Financial Statute. Justice Dr. Sobhitha Rajakaruna, delivering the judgment, highlighted that Section 21(1) imposes a statutory obligation upon the Secretary, Manager, Director, or other principal officer of a company to perform all acts required under the Statute by that company. This provision, the Court noted, places explicit statutory responsibility on the principal officer.
The Court clarified that the Magistrate did not substitute Ukwatte for the 3rd Respondent Company as the primary taxpayer, nor did it impose an independent personal tax assessment on him. Instead, Ukwatte’s liability arose as a consequence of the company’s failure to comply with the court order, linked to his statutory obligation as the principal officer under Section 21(1).
The judgment further underscored Ukwatte’s voluntary participation in the proceedings, filing an affidavit as Chairman and principal officer. The Court observed that having participated in that capacity and challenged the order, Ukwatte could not later rely on the technicality that he was not separately named as the “defaulter” in the certificate, especially when the company itself had not challenged the primary order to pay.
Drawing parallels with analogous recovery provisions in the Employees’ Provident Fund Act, the Supreme Court emphasized that revenue recovery statutes should receive a purposive construction to prevent mechanisms from becoming ineffective. The Court stated that such an interpretation is vital for securing public revenue and preventing companies from frustrating recovery of legally established liabilities.
Verdict: Appeal Dismissed, Lower Court Rulings Affirmed
Ultimately, the Supreme Court found no error in the conclusion of the Court of Appeal. It answered both questions of law in the negative, qualifying that while Ukwatte was not the person primarily assessed for the tax, his liability stemmed from his statutory obligations as the principal officer and the company’s non-compliance with the Magistrate’s order.
The Court dismissed the appeal, affirming the judgment of the Court of Appeal and upholding the Magistrate’s Court order dated 27 June 2006. This ruling reinforces the principle that principal officers of companies bear significant responsibility for corporate tax compliance, with potential personal liability arising from the company’s defaults and their statutory duties.
The Supreme Court made no order for costs in the case, which was heard together with SC Appeals Nos. 35/2023 and 36/2023, with this judgment binding all parties across the interconnected appeals.
Source: Read original document

