COLOMBO, Sri Lanka – 04 November 2026 – In a significant ruling handed down today, the Supreme Court of Sri Lanka has dismissed two cross-appeals in the case of Destine Plastic (Pvt) Limited v. Seylan Bank PLC (SC/CHC/Appeal/40A/2022 together with SC/CHC/Appeal/40/2022). The apex court affirmed the judgment of the Provincial High Court of the Western Province, which had previously dismissed both the action instituted by Destine Plastic (Pvt) Limited and the claim in reconvention made by Seylan Bank PLC.
The judgment, delivered by Dr. Sobhitha Rajakaruna, J., with Mahinda Samayawardhena, J., and Sampath K.B. Wijeratne, J., concurring, concludes a protracted legal battle concerning credit facilities, loan rescheduling, and allegations of improper recovery and disclosure.
Background to the Dispute
Destine Plastic (Pvt) Limited, a manufacturer of plastic products, obtained several credit facilities from Seylan Bank PLC, secured by mortgaged immovable properties. Following difficulties in servicing these facilities, the parties agreed to a rescheduling arrangement in November 2010, outlined in an offer letter (P4) and subsequent loan agreements (V2 and V3).
Under the rescheduled terms, a principal sum of Rs. 24,209,240 was to be repaid in 60 monthly instalments with an agreed interest rate of 12% per annum. A further sum of approximately Rs. 2,964,000 was to be booked as a separate loan and waived upon full settlement of the rescheduled term loan.
The core of the dispute arose from allegations by Destine Plastic that Seylan Bank improperly appropriated payments made for the release of mortgaged properties, leading to an excess recovery. The company also claimed damages, alleging that a bank officer improperly disclosed its financial position to a third party, resulting in the sale of a property at a reduced price and substantial business losses.
Seylan Bank, conversely, denied these allegations, asserting that Destine Plastic failed to adhere to the rescheduled repayment plan and that the bank was entitled to exercise its contractual rights. The bank subsequently filed a claim in reconvention, seeking recovery of outstanding balances amounting to Rs. 3,280,872.36 under the term loan and Rs. 2,964,000 from the separate concession facility, along with interest.
High Court’s Initial Findings
The Provincial High Court of the Western Province had dismissed Destine Plastic’s claims, finding that the company had not sufficiently established its allegations of excess recovery or damages. Crucially, the High Court also dismissed Seylan Bank’s claim in reconvention, determining that the evidence, particularly the loan ledger (D5), was insufficiently reliable to prove the precise sums claimed.
Supreme Court’s Analysis and Affirmation
The Supreme Court meticulously reviewed the submissions from both parties. Counsel Shantha Jayawardena, with Mrs. Thilini Vidanagamage, appeared for Destine Plastic, while Palitha Kumarasinghe, PC, with Priyantha Alagiyawanna, represented Seylan Bank PLC.
Destine Plastic’s Appeal Dismissed
The Court agreed with the High Court that Destine Plastic failed to prove its claim of Rs. 13,025,269.03 for alleged excess recovery. While acknowledging the payments made by Destine Plastic towards releasing mortgaged properties, the Court found that the company had not produced a reliable statement of account to establish how the alleged excess recovery was calculated. The Court also affirmed that Destine Plastic failed to prove that Seylan Bank acted in breach of the rescheduled agreement by treating it as being in default, noting the company’s acknowledged difficulties in making required payments.
Regarding the claim for Rs. 30 million in business losses and Rs. 6 million for the alleged loss from the property sale, the Supreme Court found insufficient evidence to establish a causal link between the bank’s alleged conduct (improper disclosure) and the claimed losses. The Court noted that the difference between estimated market value and sale price did not automatically prove unlawful conduct or that the bank compelled the sale at a reduced price.
Seylan Bank’s Appeal Also Dismissed
Turning to Seylan Bank’s claim in reconvention, the Supreme Court upheld the High Court’s decision to dismiss it due to the unreliability of the evidence presented. While the loan ledger (D5) was admissible under Section 90C of the Evidence Ordinance, the Court emphasized that admissibility does not equate to reliability or sufficient weight for proof.
The Court highlighted “material inconsistencies and omissions” in D5, including unreflected payments by Destine Plastic and an incorrect loan grant date. The bank’s witness also gave inconsistent evidence. The Supreme Court underscored that a bank seeking to recover a specific amount must establish that sum with credible and reliable evidence, which Seylan Bank failed to do. The same reasoning applied to the separate claim for Rs. 2,964,000, linked to the waived concession facility, as the evidential basis for its precise amount was not sufficiently reliable.
Furthermore, the Court concluded that relief sought in respect of mortgage bonds was dependent on proving the precise outstanding sums, which the bank had failed to do to the required standard.
Conclusion
The Supreme Court’s judgment reaffirms the principle that each party in a legal dispute bears the burden of proving its own claims with reliable evidence. The decision clarifies that while a borrower’s default on contractual obligations may be established, it does not automatically translate into a decree for the lender unless the precise outstanding amount is meticulously proven. Similarly, a borrower alleging improper conduct and excess recovery must provide clear and reliable evidence to substantiate those claims.
Both appeals were dismissed, with no order for costs in either appeal.
Source: Read original document

