Supreme Court Upholds Land Title, Dismissing Prescriptive Claim in Warankulasooriya v. Somasiri Appuhamy Appeal

Colombo, Sri Lanka – 17 September 2026 – The Supreme Court of Sri Lanka today delivered a pivotal judgment in the long-running land dispute case of Warankulasooriya Annette v. W.A. Somasiri Appuhamy and Others (SC Appeal 27/2016), affirming the Plaintiff’s title to a disputed property in Katuneriya and dismissing the 2nd Defendant-Appellant’s claim of prescriptive title.

The landmark decision, delivered by a bench comprising Justices Mahinda Samayawardhena, Dr. Sobhitha Rajakaruna, and Menaka Wijesundera, with the lead judgment authored by Dr. Sobhitha Rajakaruna, J., underscores critical principles of property law, particularly concerning the distinction between permissive and adverse possession.

Background to the Decades-Long Dispute

The case originated in the District Court of Marawila on 28 July 1986, when Plaintiff-Respondent-Respondent, Warankulasooriya Annette (also known as Yvonne Thamel), instituted action against W.A. Daniel Appuhamy (deceased, whose heirs were later substituted) and W.A. Somasiri Appuhamy (the 2nd Defendant), seeking a declaration of title to the land called “Ambagahawatta,” ejectment of the defendants, and damages. The Plaintiff’s claim was primarily founded on Deed No. 5077 dated 8 March 1984, executed in her favour by her husband, K. Romel Thamel, who asserted title through long possession and cultivation.

The Defendants, in turn, denied the Plaintiff’s title and claimed prescriptive title, asserting uninterrupted and independent possession of approximately 60 perches of the land for over 50 years.

In 2007, the District Court, while granting the Plaintiff relief such as demarcation, ejectment, and damages, crucially did not grant a declaration of title, concluding that the Plaintiff had failed to establish her title. The Defendants’ claim in reconvention was dismissed.

Aggrieved by this outcome, the 2nd Defendant appealed to the Provincial High Court of the North Western Province in Kurunegala, which, in a judgment dated 11 March 2014, dismissed the appeal and upheld the District Court’s decision. The High Court had notably held that the original 1st Defendant and the 2nd Defendant were mere licensees of the Plaintiff’s predecessor-in-title.

Supreme Court’s Deliberation: Permissive vs. Adverse Possession

The primary questions before the Supreme Court revolved around the Plaintiff’s asserted title, the nature and legal effect of the Defendants’ possession, the finding of a licence, and the Defendants’ claim to prescriptive title. The 2nd Defendant-Appellant-Appellant, W.A. Somasiri Appuhamy, challenged the lower courts’ findings, particularly arguing that the Plaintiff had failed to establish a valid title and that their possession was adverse, leading to prescriptive rights.

Dr. Sobhitha Rajakaruna, J., in the lead judgment, meticulously evaluated the evidence, placing significant emphasis on an admission made by Daniel Appuhamy (the original 1st defendant) in an earlier case (Case No. 121/L). In his Answer dated 10 August 1978 (marked P7), Daniel Appuhamy expressly stated that the land had been possessed by Thamel for over 30 years and that he himself had entered into possession under Thamel’s “leave and licence.”

The Court highlighted that this document provided crucial contemporaneous evidence regarding the source and nature of Daniel Appuhamy’s initial possession. It was deemed a fundamental distinction, establishing that the Defendants’ initial entry was not in assertion of an independent or hostile title, but rather pursuant to permission granted by the Plaintiff’s predecessor.

The judgment reiterated a core principle of property law: possession commencing with permission or licence cannot, by the mere passage of time, transform into adverse possession capable of conferring prescriptive title. For such possession to become adverse, there must be a clear and unequivocal repudiation of the title of the person who granted permission, and this repudiation must be brought to that person’s knowledge.

While the Defendants’ subsequent attempt to construct a permanent house might have signified an assertion of independent right, the Supreme Court concluded that this occurred at a much later stage and did not satisfy the statutory period required for prescriptive title, especially given the 2nd Defendant’s own admission of being away from the land for a substantial period while serving in the Sri Lanka Army.

The Court also rejected the 2nd Defendant’s argument that documentary evidence proving physical occupation assisted his prescriptive claim, noting that “Physical possession and prescriptive possession are not synonymous.”

The Verdict

In its decision today, 17 September 2026, the Supreme Court upheld the High Court’s findings, concluding that the Plaintiff had indeed established her title to the land based on the title and rights of her predecessor, K. Romel Thamel, and the subsequent transfer via Deed No. 5077. Conversely, the 2nd Defendant failed to establish any superior or prescriptive title to the disputed land.

The Court answered the key questions upon which Leave to Appeal was granted in favour of the Plaintiff:

  • The Civil Appellate High Court of Kurunegala did not err in holding that the original 1st Defendant and the Petitioner were licensees of the Plaintiff’s predecessor-in-title.
  • The Civil Appellate High Court of Kurunegala did not err in holding that the Plaintiff had acquired title to the land in suit.

While dismissing the 2nd Defendant’s appeal and affirming the High Court’s judgment, the Supreme Court varied the order on costs. Considering the circumstances of the case, the Plaintiff was not entitled to costs in the Supreme Court or the High Court.

This judgment serves as a significant reaffirmation of the legal distinction between permissive and adverse possession in Sri Lankan property law, emphasizing that a long period of occupation alone is insufficient to establish prescriptive title if the possession originated with the permission of the true owner.

Source: Read original document

LankaBIZ
AI Business
Intelligence
Sri Lanka Stock Market

Sri Lanka Stocks. Powered by AI.

Discover opportunities in the Colombo Stock Exchange. Screen listed companies, explore AI-powered insights and practise your investment strategies with LankaBIZ.

✓ CSE Stock Screening
✓ AI Stock Discovery
✓ Simulated Trading
✓ Market Intelligence
Explore LankaBIZ